Manchester United have lost ability to do 'dark arts of transfers', says football writer Andy Mitten
27 September 2020, 07:39 | Updated: 27 September 2020, 12:20
Manchester United have lost the ability to do the "dark arts of transfers" and supporters have received "mixed messages" from the club, according to football writer Andy Mitten.
United bought Donny van de Beek from Ajax in a deal worth up to £39m, but the midfielder remains their only summer arrival despite efforts to sign £108m-rated Borussia Dortmund winger Jadon Sancho and Porto left-back Alex Telles.
- Last-gasp drama as Man Utd snatch Brighton win
- Why Man Utd were able to win after final whistle
- Man Utd transfer rumours
Throughout the summer, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's side have also been linked with moves for Gareth Bale and Sergio Reguilon - who have both joined Tottenham - and new Liverpool midfielder Thiago Alcantara.
- Download the Transfer Talk Podcast on: Spotify | Apple | Spreaker
United manager Solskjaer says the club are "working hard" in the transfer market and could do more business before October 5, but the lack of activity so far in this window has led to widespread fan discontent.
Mitten - the editor of fanzine United We Stand - says supporters do not believe in the club's strategy and referred to a recent conversation he had with a former United player.
"United fans do not have a lot of faith in the club's recruitment policy. They feel that there has been mixed messages," Mitten told Sky Sports News.
"Back in March/April, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer said the club could perhaps take advantage of the coronavirus situation because they might be in a stronger financial position, but at one point United were the only Premier League team not to sign a single player in this transfer window.
"One former player said to me this week - a legendary United player - that the club have lost the ability to do the dark arts of transfers and he gave an example.
"If Sir Alex Ferguson wanted a player, the player would know that Ferguson wanted him, would know where he was going to play and he'd be sold the dream. Then he'd go to his agent and say 'look, I want to leave.'
"It's very difficult for a club then to negotiate when they know that player wants to leave to go to Manchester United.
"It was this player's opinion that those dark arts have been lost and you can see it, because United have been linked to all of these players and they don't often have any control with agents linking their players to the club.
"It's very frustrating for fans because they're getting completely mixed messages and they've seen just one player come in so far.
"I don't think anyone has the same pulling power as Sir Alex Ferguson but to be fair to Ole, he's been putting calls in and I know he's spoken to several managers about players who he likes.
"He's doing detailed background checks and I don't think the blame lies with him. It's the club's recruitment system which has not worked since Sir Alex Ferguson moved on."
- 146 live PL games + EFL for just £18 p/m | All Sky Sports' offers for the new season
- Live on Sky Sports | 146 Premier League games to be shown live on Sky Sports
'Lack of competition costing United'
United finished third in the Premier League last season - significant progress on the previous campaign - but trailed champions Liverpool by 33 points and second-placed Manchester City by 15.
Their last-gasp 3-2 win at Brighton on Saturday secured their first three points of 2020/21 but it was a disappointing display. It followed last week's defeat to Crystal Palace, and Mitten believes it highlights the need for more competition in the squad.
- Listen to the Sky Sports Pitch to Post Podcast on: Spotify | Apple | Castbox | Spreaker
"United have played two league games and played pretty poorly in both of them. Deserved to lose against Palace and were very lucky to win against Brighton. The issue here is the manager doesn't feel he has competition in all positions," Mitten said.
"Victor Lindelof probably wouldn't have started yesterday if Ole Gunnar Solskjaer felt he had more competition. Lindelof has played well in the past and will probably play well in the future - he played very well against Manchester City for example - but there's a lack of competition.
"United felt they needed more competition in midfield, that's why Donny van de Beek has come in. They feel they need more competition up front, because what happens if one of those brilliant top three players gets injured? That's why Jadon Sancho has been the main target.
"They want more competition at left-back as well. Judging by the way the defence played at Brighton, they need more competition right across the back.
"United fans aren't happy. It's been a poor transfer window in their eyes. Only one player has come in, United are struggling to get rid of players. Players who earn too much money and who have been given contracts. Do these players want to play football, or do they just want to pick up the money and sit on the bench?
"The squad is absolutely massive but the fact that against Brighton Ole Gunnar Solskjaer felt he couldn't play another player instead of Victor Lindelof shows how little confidence he has in the other defenders at Manchester United."
Watch Manchester United's trip to Brighton in the Carabao Cup, live on Sky Sports Football from 7.30pm on Wednesday; kick-off 7.45pm.
Manchester United then return to league action to host Tottenham, live on Sky Sports Premier League from 4pm next Sunday; kick-off 4.30pm.
Summer transfer window - key dates and times
The summer transfer window closes at 11pm on Monday October 5 with a feast of activity lined up on Transfer Deadline Day on Sky Sports News and across our Sky Sports platforms.
A domestic-only window for deals between the Premier League and EFL then runs from October 5 and closes on Friday October 16 at 5pm. Follow all the news and analysis on SSN and across Sky Sports' digital platforms, including with our dedicated Transfer Centre blog.